Oil and Gas

THE OPEN MINE DOCTRINE

 

The Open Mine Doctrine applies to property in which a life estate has been created, and there is a life tenant and remaindermen to the ownership.  The common law open mine doctrine provides:

The life tenant may not open a new mine on the property because to do so would waste the resources of the remaindermen.  The life tenant, however, may continue to work and profit from old mines on the property if those mines were open before the life estate was created.

 

When first established, this doctrine probably applied to coal and iron pit mining.  In application to oil and gas production, instead of being concerned with “waste,” the issue is who gets paid royalty from production on a property on which a life estate exists.

The Open Mine Doctrine relating to oil and gas production may be summarized as:

a.         If there was a producing well or wells in existence when the life estate was created, the life tenant will continue to receive all of the royalty from the wells, and the remaindermen will take nothing until termination of the life estate.

b.         If there was no producing well on the property, and it was not subject to an oil and gas lease when the life estate was created, the life tenant is not entitled to royalty on any new lease, but is allowed to “use” the royalty for life.  This usually means the life tenant’s royalty share is held in trust and the tenant receives the interest earned from the royalty (“banking” interest).  On the death of the life tenant, the remaindermen is entitled to all of the accrued royalty income.

c.         If a lease was taken prior to the creation of a life estate, and production was developed after the creation of the life estate, the Open Mine Doctrine is applied.  The life tenant gets all of the royalty for life.

This summary is the law in Texas.  Other oil and gas producing states may have variations of the Open Mine Doctrine.  When acquiring an oil and gas lease on an interest which is owned by both a life tenant and remaindermen, both the life tenant and remaindermen should execute the lease, and the laws of the state in which the property is located, will determine who is entitled to production proceeds from a well drilled on those lands.